Assuming that a rejection has been properly made final, which of the following statements is not in accordance with the patent laws, rules and procedures as related in the MPEP?
- AAn objection and requirement to delete new matter from the specification is subject to supervisory review by petition under 37 CFR 1.181.
- BA rejection of claims for lack of support by the specification (new matter) is reviewable by appeal to the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences.
- CIf both the claims and the specification contain the same new matter, and there has been both a rejection and objection by the primary examiner, the new matter issue should be decided by petition, and is not appealable.
- DIf both the claims and the specification contain the same new matter, and there has been both a rejection and objection by the examiner, the new matter issue is appealable, and should not be decided by petition.
- ENone of the above.
Show the official answer
(C) is the most correct answer. MPEP § 2163.06, under the heading “Review Of New Matter Objections And Rejections,” states “A rejection of claims is reviewable by the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences, whereas an objection and requirement to delete new matter is subject to supervisory review by petition under 37 CFR 1.181. If both the claims and specification contain new matter either directly or indirectly, and there has been both a rejection and objection by the examiner, the issue becomes appealable and should not be decided by petition.” Answer (C) is not accord with the USPTO rules and the procedures set forth in the MPEP. (A), (B) and (D) are incorrect. They are in accord with proper USPTO procedure. See MPEP § 2163.06, under the heading “Review Of New Matter Objections And Rejections.” (E) is not correct because (C) is correct. MPEP § 2163.06.
Authorities cited
- MPEP § 2163.06
- 37 CFR 1.181
Is this still good law? This question comes from the October 2003 USPTO registration exam. The explanation is the USPTO's official model answer from that exam, and its MPEP citations refer to the MPEP edition in force at the time. Section numbers and rules may have changed since; check the current MPEP before relying on it.
Want to practice with all 900 real questions, with the MPEP open beside each one? Get Patech, or try the free 20-question practice test.