Patent bar practice question: Which of the following phrases taken from an independent claim has an…

A real question from the October 2003, Morning, Q33 USPTO registration exam, with the USPTO's official model answer.

October 2003 · Morning · Q33 · Official USPTO question

Which of the following phrases taken from an independent claim has an antecedent basis problem according to the patent laws, rules and the procedures as related in the MPEP?

  1. A“the center of the circle having ...,” where the claim does not previously recite that the circle has a “center.”
  2. B“the major diameter of the ellipse being ...,” where the claim does not previously recite that the ellipse has a “major diameter.”
  3. C“the outer surface of the sphere being ...,” where the claim does not previously recite that the sphere has an “outer surface.”
  4. D“the lever of the machine being located ...,” where the claim does not previously recite a “lever.”
  5. E“the area of the rectangle being ...,” where the claim does not previously define an “area.”
Show the official answer
Official model answer: (D)

(D) is correct. "Inherent components of elements recited have antecedent basis in the recitation of the components themselves." MPEP § 2173.05(e). The MPEP provides an analogous example: "the limitation 'the outer surface of said sphere' would not require an antecedent recitation that the sphere have an outer surface." Id. (A), (B), (C), and (E) are all examples of things which inherently have the claimed characteristic and do not have an antecedent basis problem; that is, all circles have a center, all ellipses have a major diameter, all spheres have an outer surface, and all rectangles have an area, and these characteristics need not be provided with express antecedent basis. The ellipse example is from Bose Corp. v. JBL Inc., 61 USPQ2d 1216, 1219 (Fed. Cir. 2001) ("There can be no dispute that mathematically an inherent characteristic of an ellipse is a major diameter."). The lever recited in (D) is not an inherent component of a machine and therefore requires express antecedent basis.

Authorities cited

Is this still good law? This question comes from the October 2003 USPTO registration exam. The explanation is the USPTO's official model answer from that exam, and its MPEP citations refer to the MPEP edition in force at the time. Section numbers and rules may have changed since; check the current MPEP before relying on it.

Want to practice with all 900 real questions, with the MPEP open beside each one? Get Patech, or try the free 20-question practice test.