Patent bar practice question: Prosecution before the primary examiner results in the rejection of…

A real question from the October 2003, Morning, Q38 USPTO registration exam, with the USPTO's official model answer.

October 2003 · Morning · Q38 · Official USPTO question

Prosecution before the primary examiner results in the rejection of claim 1. Claim 2 was objected to as being allowable except for its dependency from claim 1. Independent claim 3 has been allowed. The rejection of claim 1 is properly appealed to the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences. The Board properly affirms the rejection of claim 1. Appellant has filed no response to the decision of the Board, the appellant has taken no action, and the time for filing an appeal to the court or a civil action has expired. In accordance with the patent laws, rules and procedures as related in the MPEP, which of the following actions is the most appropriate response by the examiner?

  1. AThe examiner should hold the application abandoned.
  2. BThe examiner should cancel claim 1, convert dependent claim 2 into independent form by examiner’s amendment, and allow the application.
  3. CThe examiner should set a 1-month time limit in which appellant may rewrite the dependent claim in independent form.
  4. DThe examiner should cancel claims 1 and 2 and allow the application with claim 3 only.
  5. ENone of the above.
Show the official answer
Official model answer: (D)

(D) is the most correct answer. 37 CFR § 1.197(c); MPEP § 1214.06. This case is specifically set forth in MPEP § 1214.06 under the heading “Claims Stand Allowed.” Answers (A), (B) and (C) apply only if no claims stand allowed in the application. They are incorrect because the facts state that claim 3 was allowed. See MPEP § 1214.06, under the heading “No Claims Stand Allowed.” (B) is incorrect. See MPEP § 1214.06 under the heading “Claims Stand Allowed.” Where one or more other claims stand allowed, the examiner is not authorized to convert to independent form a dependent claim that has been objected to (but not allowed or rejected) based on its dependency to a rejected claim. (C) is incorrect. See MPEP § 1214.06 under the heading “Claims Stand Allowed.” Where one or more other claims stand allowed, the examiner is not authorized to provide appellant with time to rewrite a dependent claim into independent form where the dependent claim was objected to (but not allowed or rejected) based on its dependency to a rejected claim.

Authorities cited

Is this still good law? This question comes from the October 2003 USPTO registration exam. The explanation is the USPTO's official model answer from that exam, and its MPEP citations refer to the MPEP edition in force at the time. Section numbers and rules may have changed since; check the current MPEP before relying on it.

Want to practice with all 900 real questions, with the MPEP open beside each one? Get Patech, or try the free 20-question practice test.